Kitchen Indigo,Kitchen MAXWELL2

[Prof4D]

Я пытаюсь сравнить Индиго, MAXWELL2

[fused]

Hey Prof4D,

nice renderings

the Indigo image looks a littel better

rendered for the same ammount of time?

[Stromberg]

The indigo render looks alot better, but the materials arnt the same in those two renders

[djegoo]

Maxwell Ownage over here!
The materials aren t the same, but they seem more "achieved" and then more complicated to calculate in general imho. am I wrong?
And moreover, not speaking about the materials in detail, the convergence is much better in indigo, but i would realy like to know how much time each rendered

nice scene too by the way Prof 4D. I don t understand the mean word but thanks for posting!

[Stromberg]

I would like to know how mutch each rendered
And the sun is stronger in the indigo image aswell, making the maxwell render look realy dull and dark.

[djegoo]

Dunno if it is because of the sun, or the way maxwell treats the colors? because i guess the walls are supposed to be 85%bright Grey in the modeler? which is white in indigo and maybe Max treat them exactly how it is in the exporter?
gonna watch on the maxwell forums or manuals if i find something, but this would mean that there is something unphysical or so in Max ? would really be anormal.

RENDER TIME!!! RENTER TIME!!! TENDER RIME!!!

[Stromberg]

Would be nice to have this scene, cause i see alot of diffrences between the 2 versions, and i have used maxwell for sometime aswell... and i am shure with some carefull tweaks atleast maxwell will have a fair chance

[djegoo]

ye i agree, but i am still very interested in a pertinent comparison of a scene in both renderers !
gonna sleep and tomorow we ll have more answers maybe

EDIT : by the way, just went on the maxwell french forum, but did not find anything, i was too lazy too, but omg it s full of immature users

[neo0.]

Indigo looks much, much better. The lighting on the maxwell one looks so washed out imo. In contrast, the indigo lighting looks a lot more "alive."

[suvakas]

Would be nice to have this scene, cause i see alot of diffrences between the 2 versions, and i have used maxwell for sometime aswell... and i am shure with some carefull tweaks atleast maxwell will have a fair chance

It's an old Evermotion scene. You can buy the DVD from their site, if you want to.

But I agree, unfortunately the comparison isn't fair and shows nothing.

[Prof4D]

Time in indigo 6 hours
The test of Maksvel I will tell later.
Me noise interests.
I perfectly know possibilities of MAXWELL.

[djegoo]

Hi Prof4D
ANy new from your maxwell test? I am really very interested in such a test done, especially if you know maxwell, it will make it very pertinent.

cheers

[benn]

It's because life is better with Indigo. ;D

[Stromberg]

Would still be nice if maxwell got a fair chance

[Godzilla]

Would still be nice if maxwell got a fair chance

Yeah.. But then Maxwell would win.