Sun with "physical lights"
Sun with "physical lights"
Is it just me, or is there a difficulty combining Sun-light with physical lights like IES or meshlights with powerdrawn/efficacy statements?
As soon as a Sun is in the Scene, the physical lights don't seem to lighten even the shadows much.
In earlier Versions of Indigo, one could simply crank up a gain parameter (or was it down?) and be done with it, but since we have all the great new physical lights, that has lost it's charme even if it's possible (didn't check, though).
In this scene, I've placed ~20 spotlights of "type 18" of the blendigo IES-Collection (I hope I recall that correctly). The Ball is a black phong and ~60cm or around that.
I'd love to check Indirect Lighting against Sun Light, so what am I missing
As soon as a Sun is in the Scene, the physical lights don't seem to lighten even the shadows much.
In earlier Versions of Indigo, one could simply crank up a gain parameter (or was it down?) and be done with it, but since we have all the great new physical lights, that has lost it's charme even if it's possible (didn't check, though).
In this scene, I've placed ~20 spotlights of "type 18" of the blendigo IES-Collection (I hope I recall that correctly). The Ball is a black phong and ~60cm or around that.
I'd love to check Indirect Lighting against Sun Light, so what am I missing
- Attachments
-
- Sky.jpg (67.49 KiB) Viewed 5158 times
1) I don't think Efficacy scale works with IES lights (bug?)
2) I noticed that the brightness of IES lights seems to affected by the size of the mesh. Try having two identical IES lights of different sizes in the same render. The larger one will overpower the smaller one. I'm not sure if this was Ono's intent.
3) From my experience, normal meshlights with typical efficacy scales work fine in combination with sun and skylight.
I haven't done many tests with IES lights. Maybe someone else can confirm my statements.
2) I noticed that the brightness of IES lights seems to affected by the size of the mesh. Try having two identical IES lights of different sizes in the same render. The larger one will overpower the smaller one. I'm not sure if this was Ono's intent.
3) From my experience, normal meshlights with typical efficacy scales work fine in combination with sun and skylight.
I haven't done many tests with IES lights. Maybe someone else can confirm my statements.
on further testing, it does appear that power_drawn and efficacy_scale are ignored with IES lights.
edit: it appears that blackbody Gain is ineffective too.
edit edit:
using
gives Light luminous flux: 600.00 lm
using
gives Light luminous flux: 3000.00 lm
edit: it appears that blackbody Gain is ineffective too.
edit edit:
using
Code: Select all
<meshlight>
<pos>0 0 0</pos>
<scale>1</scale>
<rotation><matrix>1 0 0 0 0 -1 0 1 0</matrix></rotation>
<mesh_name>IESlocator|IESlight|IESlightShape</mesh_name>
<spectrum>
<blackbody>
<temperature>6500</temperature>
<gain>1000</gain>
</blackbody>
</spectrum>
<ies_profile>
<path>../ies/18.ies</path>
</ies_profile>
<efficacy_scale>
<power_drawn>150</power_drawn>
<overall_luminous_efficacy>20</overall_luminous_efficacy>
</efficacy_scale>
</meshlight>
using
Code: Select all
<meshlight>
<pos>0 0 0</pos>
<scale>1</scale>
<rotation><matrix>1 0 0 0 0 -1 0 1 0</matrix></rotation>
<mesh_name>IESlocator|IESlight|IESlightShape</mesh_name>
<spectrum>
<blackbody>
<temperature>6500</temperature>
<gain>1000</gain>
</blackbody>
</spectrum>
<efficacy_scale>
<power_drawn>150</power_drawn>
<overall_luminous_efficacy>20</overall_luminous_efficacy>
</efficacy_scale>
</meshlight>
I think lights should get brighter as the scene get smaller, so the same luminous flux is applied to a much smaller area.I just made a quick test scene similar to bkircher's and using global scale factor on the scene to make the scene 100x smaller made the meshlights brighter.
I also think we shouldn't resort to light using severall 1000Watts of energy, with global warning and all (sorry, couldn't resist)
I've made this second test with a 40 W light-bulb (I think that fits roughly), and with a 1m cube, I'd guess there should happen something inside.
2nd image is with the equivalent of a 28W fluorescent tube ...
If I wasn't that lazy this evening, I'd check with linear exposed images.
- Attachments
-
- Sky2.jpg (63.02 KiB) Viewed 5120 times
in my last test this evening:
balances quite well with sunlight
(with reinhar tonemapping 2/1/6.5)
Code: Select all
<meshlight>
<pos>0 0 0</pos>
<scale>1</scale>
<rotation><matrix>1 0 0 0 0 -1 0 1 0</matrix></rotation>
<mesh_name>IESlocator1|IESlight|IESlightShape</mesh_name>
<spectrum>
<blackbody>
<temperature>6500</temperature>
<gain>20000</gain>
</blackbody>
</spectrum>
<efficacy_scale>
<power_drawn>3000</power_drawn>
<overall_luminous_efficacy>200</overall_luminous_efficacy>
</efficacy_scale>
</meshlight>
(with reinhar tonemapping 2/1/6.5)
I think Indigo sun brightness is probably fine. The behaviour you are seeing is probably due to Reinhard tonemapping. If you were to try an interior scene with the sunlight coming in through a window, you would probably find that typical efficacy settings work as expected (but not with IES lights ).
So we have to calibrate the plane's size in MtI. Also the trick from 0.7 (MtIFull) was doing well, but my preference goes to manual tweaking.
from log.txt
Maybe even more...Could it be that Indigo is 2 power of magnitudes off the mark as far as Sun brightness is concerned?
Code: Select all
Sky zenith luminance (cd/m^2): 10001.42853
Sun spectral radiance (Wsr^-1m^-3) at 500nm: 18024505540608.000000
obsolete asset
Hrmm ok, a lot of questions to answer.
" I don't think Efficacy scale works with IES lights (bug?) "
There is no need for the efficacy scale element if ies_profile is present. This is because the efficacy_scale just defines the total luminous flux emitted by the light, but the .ies file has that information already.
The efficacy_scale element is ignored if ies_profile is present.
"There is a HUGE intensity difference between the sun and meshlights... they are difficult to balance. "
Yes well it may be difficult, but I think it's correct.
"2) I noticed that the brightness of IES lights seems to affected by the size of the mesh. Try having two identical IES lights of different sizes in the same render. The larger one will overpower the smaller one. I'm not sure if this was Ono's intent.
"
Changing the size of an IES light has no effect on the total power emitted in my tests.
"Could it be that Indigo is 2 power of magnitudes off the mark as far as Sun brightness is concerned?"
It *could* be, but I think Indigo is correct. If you have actual comparisons with real life lighting situations or data, please feel free to share, otherwise you're just speculating.
" I don't think Efficacy scale works with IES lights (bug?) "
There is no need for the efficacy scale element if ies_profile is present. This is because the efficacy_scale just defines the total luminous flux emitted by the light, but the .ies file has that information already.
The efficacy_scale element is ignored if ies_profile is present.
"There is a HUGE intensity difference between the sun and meshlights... they are difficult to balance. "
Yes well it may be difficult, but I think it's correct.
"2) I noticed that the brightness of IES lights seems to affected by the size of the mesh. Try having two identical IES lights of different sizes in the same render. The larger one will overpower the smaller one. I'm not sure if this was Ono's intent.
"
Changing the size of an IES light has no effect on the total power emitted in my tests.
"Could it be that Indigo is 2 power of magnitudes off the mark as far as Sun brightness is concerned?"
It *could* be, but I think Indigo is correct. If you have actual comparisons with real life lighting situations or data, please feel free to share, otherwise you're just speculating.
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 43 guests