indigo's inaccuracy of blend mode (materials / textures):
the borders of the plane remain visible, although it must be invisible.
can you fix it in next releases?
thanks.
p.s. i attach zip'ped cinema 4d r20 scene.
inaccuracy of blend mode (materials / textures)
inaccuracy of blend mode (materials / textures)
- Attachments
-
- blend errors.zip
- (74.6 KiB) Downloaded 242 times
- Originalplan®
- Posts: 757
- Joined: Sat Sep 26, 2015 8:58 pm
- 3D Software: Cinema 4D
- Contact:
Re: inaccuracy of blend mode (materials / textures)
Hey wob.
I tested your scene. It seems that it is rather your setups fault then Indigo being inaccurate.
Just copied your materials blend noise to a normal c4d material, and you can still see the same edge being there on a normal color channel. Thus it's a normal behavior for c4d also, and has to do with the noise overflowing your object.
I tested your scene. It seems that it is rather your setups fault then Indigo being inaccurate.
Just copied your materials blend noise to a normal c4d material, and you can still see the same edge being there on a normal color channel. Thus it's a normal behavior for c4d also, and has to do with the noise overflowing your object.
- Originalplan®
- Posts: 757
- Joined: Sat Sep 26, 2015 8:58 pm
- 3D Software: Cinema 4D
- Contact:
Re: inaccuracy of blend mode (materials / textures)
A good rule of thumb is with noise in general, to handle them as patterns (since they are patterns) aka somewhere on the object & seeds it will repeat like a tile pattern.
Re: inaccuracy of blend mode (materials / textures)
no, it's not a normal behavior of indigo. because i tested blend mode with png (black & white) images too and got the same thing (black borders instead clean alpha). it's not a cinema 4d problem becase you can see how standart physical render made it (zip`ped scene attached):Originalplan® wrote: ↑Mon Mar 23, 2020 4:01 amHey wob.
I tested your scene. It seems that it is rather your setups fault then Indigo being inaccurate.
Just copied your materials blend noise to a normal c4d material, and you can still see the same edge being there on a normal color channel. Thus it's a normal behavior for c4d also, and has to do with the noise overflowing your object.
but!
i found that this problem of indigo appers only this uvw mode of texture. in cubic mode there is no black borders with noise patterns:
- Attachments
-
- physical.zip
- (89.26 KiB) Downloaded 246 times
- Originalplan®
- Posts: 757
- Joined: Sat Sep 26, 2015 8:58 pm
- 3D Software: Cinema 4D
- Contact:
Re: inaccuracy of blend mode (materials / textures)
but!
By me even in cubic mode I get the error c4d is showing me in the view. Even in your physical scene c4d shows me an error in the viewport. That I mentioned earlier.
And after rendering the same error shows up in Indigo.
So Indigo is correct to viewport. Why c4d does not show it in his own physical renderer I don't know.
You didn't had a UV map on your object so it can be UV related ofc.i found that this problem of indigo appers only this uvw mode of texture. in cubic mode there is no black borders with noise patterns:
By me even in cubic mode I get the error c4d is showing me in the view. Even in your physical scene c4d shows me an error in the viewport. That I mentioned earlier.
And after rendering the same error shows up in Indigo.
So Indigo is correct to viewport. Why c4d does not show it in his own physical renderer I don't know.
Re: inaccuracy of blend mode (materials / textures)
i attached no viewport screenshots, but final rendering images. you can test it with any png black and white image as alpha blend and you'll get the same result with black borders on the final renderings (in cinema 4d or in indigo standalone). perhaps it's problem with uvw texture tag. i didnt get the same problem with another render engines.Originalplan® wrote: ↑Mon Mar 23, 2020 9:40 am
You didn't had a UV map on your object so it can be UV related ofc.
By me even in cubic mode I get the error c4d is showing me in the view. Even in your physical scene c4d shows me an error in the viewport. And after rendering the same error shows up in Indigo.
So Indigo is correct to viewport. Why c4d does not show it in his own physical renderer I don't know.
- thesquirell
- Posts: 428
- Joined: Fri Aug 29, 2014 3:49 am
- Location: Novi Sad, Serbia
Re: inaccuracy of blend mode (materials / textures)
Hey there wob!
Never encountered a problem like this. But after recreating a scene in couple of scenarios I managed to reproduce it, and solve it by adding a slight padding on the edges of the uv unwrap. It's an usual practice in gaming industry, since it reduces bleeding. But I'm not sure if it will work in all scenarios, especially if you are using c4d's shaders and effects, and baking them.
Never encountered a problem like this. But after recreating a scene in couple of scenarios I managed to reproduce it, and solve it by adding a slight padding on the edges of the uv unwrap. It's an usual practice in gaming industry, since it reduces bleeding. But I'm not sure if it will work in all scenarios, especially if you are using c4d's shaders and effects, and baking them.
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 82 guests